6

My r-xsr receiver short circuited after a crash recently. When investigating the reason, I found two things; The filtering capacitor had come loose, as well as one of the antennae on the r-xsr.

Since the reviver can handle up to 10 volts, and it was connected to a 5 V output on the FC, I assume the capacitor isn't the problem. So my question is therefore: can this problem have been caused by the drone being powered up when the antenna came loose?

9

Running a receiver without an antenna should not cause any damage to the receiver, as no RF power is sent to the antenna (if your receiver has an active antenna there may be a DC bias present, but this does not cause problems - you will often see this in GPS receivers.)

However, for completeness, it is worth noting that some modern RC receivers actually do transmit, to send telemetry and other data back to the controller; in this case 'receiver' is a misnomer, used to mean "the radio part in the aircraft" - and it is possible for damage to occur. The correct term would be 'transceiver', a portmanteau of 'transmitter' and 'receiver'.

The reason a transmitter can be damaged when run without an antenna is because the power sent to the antenna has nowhere to go. When a (matched) antenna is connected, the power is transferred to the antenna but without it the energy is reflected back down the transmission line to the output transistors. These transistors are not designed to handle that much power coming back, and can fail. The likelihood of this happening generally increases with transmit power, but it also depends on the rating of the output transistors so this is just a crude approximation.
(Transmission line theory deviates somewhat from the normal models of power transfer, where having nowhere for the power to go would create an open circuit, and no current flows.)

| improve this answer | |
  • 1
    Okay, thanks. Then it is possible that is the cause since the r-xsr sends telemetry back to the radio – Hannes Hultergård Jun 23 at 19:37

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.